CCalclabhub

Finance · 109 calculators

Rent Vs Buy Calculator

Rent versus buy is not a comparison of rent with a mortgage payment. Owning costs the down payment, the loan, taxes, insurance and maintenance, but it returns the equity and any appreciation at sale.

Last updated

Net cost to own

$148,899.29

Total cost of renting
$183,899.09
Home value at sale
$491,949.55
Loan balance at sale
$289,331.98
Owning advantage
$34,999.80

Values update as you type. This calculator covers the single scenario its formula assumes — see Common Mistakes for what it leaves out.

The formula this calculator uses

Net cost to own = down payment + payments + tax + maintenance + insurance - sale proceeds

down
Cash paid at purchase
payments
Total mortgage payments made
proceeds
Sale price minus selling costs and the remaining loan
rent
Total rent paid over the same years

How to check the result by hand

  1. 1

    Add up the cost of owning

    Total the down payment, the mortgage payments over the years, property tax, maintenance and insurance. These are the outflows of ownership.

  2. 2

    Estimate the sale proceeds

    Grow the home price by the appreciation rate, subtract selling costs, and subtract the remaining loan balance. This is the cash returned at sale.

  3. 3

    Net the two for the cost of owning

    Subtract the sale proceeds from the total outflows. A large positive number means owning was expensive; a small or negative one means it was cheap.

  4. 4

    Total the rent over the same years

    Compound the monthly rent by the annual increase and sum it across the years. This is the true cost of renting, not twelve months times the years.

  5. 5

    Compare and check the horizon

    The lower net cost wins. Re-run at different horizons to find the break-even, the number of years you must stay for buying to come out ahead.

Common Questions

How does the Rent Vs Buy Calculator work?

Add everything you spend on owning, then subtract the cash you get back when you sell after repaying the loan. Compare that net cost with the total rent over the same years. A 400,000 home held seven years can end up about 35,000 cheaper than renting, once the sale proceeds are counted.

What do I need to enter in the Rent Vs Buy Calculator?

It takes 12 inputs: Home price, Down payment (percent), Mortgage rate (percent), Loan term (years), Years to compare, Monthly rent, Rent increase per year (percent), Home appreciation per year (percent), Property tax per year (percent), Maintenance per year (percent), Home insurance (annual), Selling cost (percent). Fields that expect a unit say so next to the label.

Where does Net cost to own come from?

It comes from Net = down + payments + tax + maintenance + insurance - sale proceeds — everything spent on owning, less the cash recovered at sale.

What is the most common mistake with the Rent Vs Buy Calculator?

Comparing rent with the mortgage payment. The mortgage payment is only part of the cost of owning. A fair comparison includes tax, insurance, maintenance and the down payment, then credits the sale proceeds.

For worked examples, common mistakes and the limits of this formula, read the full How To Calculate Rent Vs Buy page.